Common Conditions that Give Rise to a Premises Liability Case

Haggard Law Firm > Crime Victim Attorney  > Common Conditions that Give Rise to a Premises Liability Case

Common Conditions that Give Rise to a Premises Liability Case

On August 16th, 2018 The Haggard Law Firm will present Winning Case Strategies in Premises Liability, a FREE CLE Credit Seminar. The event will take place from 1 to 5pm at the Doubletree Jacksonville Riverfront. To RSVP for the seminar, email or call Stacy at   305.446.5700 

This article about premises liability cases was authored by trial lawyer and Haggard Law partner Douglas McCarron who will be one of the presenters at the CLE Seminar

Common Conditions that Give Rise to a Premises Liability Case

by Douglas Mccarron

In my experience, the most common condition in any premises liability case is the lack of guardianship of the property.  In most instances, the property owner and/or manager fails to put in place policies and procedures that ensure that the premises is kept in a reasonably safe condition.  For example, in many negligent security cases it becomes obvious that the owner and management fail to do anything that assesses violent crime occurring at the property.  Without knowing what type of crime is happening, it is nearly impossible to know what type of security measures are needed.  How can the owner make decisions about access control, manned security, and surveillance cameras, if they have failed to gather the crime statistics for the property and the surrounding area?  The answer is simple, they do not know and consequently violent crime continues to victimize the property’s guests and invitees.  In slip and fall cases, many properties fail to ensure that their employees follow the internal policies and procedures to maintain the property in a safe manner.  This leads to dangerous conditions being left on the property for an unacceptable amount of time. 

If property owners simply prepare policies and procedures for their employees to follow and have appropriate supervision to ensure that the policies and procedures are being followed, then the most dangerous conditions would cease to exist.  Obviously, financial considerations come into play for the property owners.  In developing a premises liability case, it is important to discover exactly what property owners are failing to do and why they are failing to do it.  Jurors do not appreciate property owners turning a blind eye and pleading ignorance.  Jurors also do not accept that the owners do not want to put the necessary resources (money) into the property to make it safe.



As an example, my partner Todd Michaels was able to secure a $2.65 million dollar verdict in a negligent security case in Clay County, Florida where the management was their residents’ AND their own worst enemy.   The facts of the case demonstrated that the property knew that there was a upswing in crime at the property.  Instead of being proactive, the property owner allowed the access control gates to remain broken for over 6 months.  The property owner’s failure caused the death of our client during a burglary attempt to his sister’s home.    This is a prime example of how juries will find for a victim in light of a property owner refusing to make their property safe.

As discussed, when preparing a premises liability case, it is extremely important to go through what policies and procedures a property owner has put into place and whether they are being followed.   Just as important is why a property owner is failing to take the reasonable steps to make sure that the property is safe.   Get all written policies and procedures as soon as possible – send written discovery requesting this information with the filing of the Complaint.  Follow this with detailed depositions of management and the property employees.  Armed with this information, it will become easy to show that the property owner and/or management dug their head in the sand and were at fault for your client’s injury or death.

To learn more about the Haggard Law Firm

About Douglas McCarron

Partner Douglas J. McCarron is an accomplished trial lawyer with significant experience handling a wide variety of cases including negligent security, pool drowning, dram shop, and construction and auto accidents.

Doug served as an Assistant State Attorney in Miami-Dade County for four years. While there, Doug was a member of the Career Criminal Unit where he distinguished himself in over 50 trials prosecuting violent crime. Upon leaving the State Attorney’s Office in 2000, Doug began to focus on representing victims of serious and catastrophic injury.

to read full bio

1 Comment

  • Rosalia Tompai
    Reply December 6, 2018 at 12:55 pm

    Good morning! I’ve been researching premise liability due to a situation that occurred recently on a rental property that I am still residing in. Recently, I had a plumber come into the home and caused the overflow of the toilet to occur. This plumber has been pursuing for a year the work to replace the old galvanized pipes and used this opportunity to do a simply toilet replacement to tear into the bathroom wall and have the debri that clogged the main pipelines. Needless to say, he managed to obtain the green light from the owner to do so. While doing the work, the plumber was negligent in contaminating my home with fecal matter and overflow frrom the sewer line that flooded the inside of my home. Carpet, walls and furniture was soaking wet. The plumber nor the owner had any professional cleaning company do In fact, I did the cleaning myself and had no idea how serious this situation was, with respect to proper cleaning and the hazards present in the home. The plumber left a bucket under the home to collect the waste coming from toilet and water that was being dumped into the huge whole outside of the bathroom where he removed the pipes and did not return for a few days. At this point I called ;the owner and no avail, the fire dept for injuries sustained to insects biting me, channel 3 news to report and obtain help from the local news. I ended up in urgent care and did receive medical attention for the same. I have photographs , bills and estimates regarding my damages. There are more circumstances surrounding this event, however i would like to discuss my case with your law firm for representation of the same.

Post a Reply to Rosalia Tompai Cancel Reply